1. Religion & Spirituality
Send to a Friend via Email

Discuss in my forum

Austin Cline

Christian Right's War Against Condoms

By May 23, 2005

Follow me on:

The Christian Right has long waged a war against access to abortion; now they are targeting contraception. The Christian Right is a driving force behind the growth of abstinence-only education programs that are designed to mislead students about condoms and, as a consequence, they increase the chances of risky sexual behavior.

CBS News reports on their investigation of Denny Pattyn's "Silver Ring Thing" program, a federally-funded religious program that promotes abstinence and denies the effectiveness of condoms:

Pattyn doesnít just preach the virtues of sexual abstinence. His show is full of negative messages about condoms Ė messages warning that condoms wonít protect kids from pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases.

"We spoke with some of the kids after the show in Fort Meyers and they said that going into the program they thought that condoms did work, but your show convinced them that they didnít," says Bradley to Pattyn.

"Right. Well, thatís good because we believe that condoms arenít the answer," says Pattyn.

"A kidís part of your program, and he comes to you and says, 'You know, Iím going to have sex. Iíve reached a point and Iím going to do this. Should I use a condom?' What do you say?" asks Bradley.

"My own daughter, my 16-year-old daughter, tells me sheís going to be sexually active. I would not tell her to use a condom," says Pattyn. "I don't think it'll protect her. It wonít protect her heart. It wonít protect her emotional life. And itís not going to protect her. I donít want her to get out there and think that sheís going to be protected using a condom."

That's right, Denny Pattyn wouldn't even tell his own children to use a condom ó even though it would protect their health and might prevent pregnancy, it wouldnít protect their hearts. Of course, not having a condom also wouldn't protect their hearts, but why quibble over little details like that?

But wouldn't his daughter be more protected with a condom than without? "Not long term," says Pattyn.

Actually, his daughter would be better of with a condom than without ó if we are thinking about her physical health. Condoms help prevent pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. I don't think that's what Pattyn means by "long-term," though. I think that he is talking about her soul.

According to the religious ideology of people like Pattyn, any sex outside marriage jeopardizes one's soul and teaching about condoms might encourage such sex. It's better to risk AIDS or pregnancy and keep one's soul than know how to prevent AIDS and pregnancy and risk going to hell.

Abstinence-only programs can get young people to delay having sex, but attitudes like this have negative consequences:

"The downside is that, when they have sex, pledgers are one-third less likely to use condoms at first sex," says [Columbia Universityís Peter Bearman, who co-authored the most comprehensive study ever done on adolescent health and sexuality]. "So all of the benefit of the delay in terms of pregnancy-risk and in terms of STD acquisition -- poof -- it just disappears because theyíre so much less likely to use a condom at first sex."

"Theyíve been taught that condoms donít work; theyíre fearful of them. They donít know how to use them," says Bearman. "Their peers donít use them. They have no experience with them. They donít know how to get them. Theyíre had to get access to. For whatever reason they donít use them, that has long-term consequences."

At least their souls will be safe, right? Bearman has also found that teens who take virginity pledges like those that are part of the Silver Ring Thing are much more likely to engage in riskier sex eventually. Such a high premium is placed on technical virginity that sexual desire finds other outlets:

"Adolescents who take virginity pledges Ė who remain virgins, that is, who donít have vaginal sex, who technically remain virgins, are much more likely to have oral and anal sex," says Bearman. ... "They're much less likely to get tested for a sexually transmitted disease. Theyíve taken a public pledge to remain a virgin until marriage. The sex that they have is much more likely to be hidden," says Bearman. "Itís likely to be hidden from their parents. Itís likely to be hidden from their peers. And if they live in a small community, itís quite likely to be hidden from their doctor."

"Thereís a group of people who are using abstinence as a vehicle, pretending to be concerned about public health," says Bearman. "But itís really a vehicle to advance a program, a cultural program that doesnít help public health."

In abstinence-only programs, teachers aren't allowed to tell the truth about condoms - like how they are nearly always effective when used properly. Teachers also aren't allowed to explain how to use them or where to get them. That's right, teachers aren't allowed to tell their students the truth because the truth conflicts with the religious agenda of the Christian Right, an agenda that is being funded by the taxpayers.

Read More:

Comments
July 20, 2007 at 12:47 am
(1) Al says:

THIS IS RIDICULOUS. NOT EVERYONE WHO SAYS THEY ARE A CHRISTIAN IS A CHRISTIAN. ITS JUST LIKE THESE ATHEISTS I DEBATE THAT TELL ME HITLER WAS CHRISTIAN. I WANT TO WRAP DUCT TAPE AROUND MY HEAD. BEING A CHRISTIAN MEANS YOU FOLLOW JESUS CHRIST! YOU ARE NOT A CHRISTIAN BECAUSE OF A MERE PROFESSION. JESUS SAID “WHY DO YOU CALL ME LORD, LORD, WHEN YOU DO NOT DO THE THINGS THAT I TELL YOU?” THIS IS HYPOCRISY AND A MISREPRESENTATION OF TRUE CHRISTIANITY.

July 20, 2007 at 6:17 am
(2) Austin Cline says:

THIS IS RIDICULOUS. NOT EVERYONE WHO SAYS THEY ARE A CHRISTIAN IS A CHRISTIAN.

As far as outsiders are concerned, no one who claims to be a Christian has any greater claim to the label than anyone else. Your denunciations of others carries no more weight than the pope’s

October 13, 2009 at 12:31 pm
(3) Pastor Musa Luzali says:

Using condoms among christians society is a way of rebelion the word of our Lord,If Lord has said no practice of sexual immorality who could do againist the Lord? If person says is a christian and do not follow what Jesus says is not christian real.Condom in the christians ream is wrong.

October 20, 2009 at 2:45 pm
(4) Todd says:

Is English a foreign language to you or are you stupid AND ignorant instead of merely ignorant?

The planet is horrifically over populated and is getting worse every day. W/O condoms it would be far worse still. W/O condoms AIDS would be as common as the cold.

Keep your bronze age superstitions off my junk.

October 20, 2009 at 6:25 pm
(5) John Hanks says:

All religions are fertility cults. That is the only reason for objecting to condoms.

October 20, 2009 at 7:18 pm
(6) Bill T says:

It never ceases to amaze me how much disinformation is put out there by the Christian Right about sex-and this is 2009-unbelievable-when are the chastity belts going to be handed out along with the textbooks????

October 21, 2009 at 2:15 am
(7) Dan says:

Re: (4)
Todd, I’m 99% sure that (3) is an example of English as a Foreign Language, and it’s pretty rude to criticize someone’s EFL abilities like that. Even if they are a dirty theist.
After all, 90%+ of the internet is in English, so any attempt at joining in should be applauded. Maybe he’ll learn more English, read more of this site, and quit propagating the mental virus of religion.

April 29, 2010 at 2:45 am
(8) Disciple: Brandon says:

“Is English a foreign language to you or are you stupid AND ignorant instead of merely ignorant?

The planet is horrifically over populated and is getting worse every day. W/O condoms it would be far worse still. W/O condoms AIDS would be as common as the cold.

Keep your bronze age superstitions off my junk.”

wait for it, wait for it, wait… hold, hold…..

ok then. stop having sex….. problem solved!!!!!! YAY!!!!

God Said be fruitful and multiply.

Sex was created first and foremost to procreate. secondly it was created pleasurable by the LORD God of all creation because He made us sexual beings (hence why he covered Adam and Eve after the fall) and because He loves us and wants us to be happy.

Ta da! how ’bout them apples.

**Sorry for you ESL people who don’t understand the phrase**

ps, instead of passing out condoms in Africa how about we set up schools for women and teach them the health benefits of things such as abstaining (#1 stopper for the spread of AIDS, i can guarantee that, especially since condoms don’t guarantee against STD’s), planning, and learning to use one’s body as more than just an inlet for sleazy guys looking to get some tush for dirt cheap because the woman cant get a job and needs to feed her 6 younger siblings because both of their parents died from AIDS….

game. set. match.

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.